How Much Does Retirement Spending Drop? The Real Smile Curve
Does your spending really fall once you retire, or is that wishful thinking? You have probably heard that you only need a slice of your old paycheck to live well in retirement. That idea is helpful, but it is not the full story. Your costs shift, your habits stick around, and a few surprise line items show up right on cue.
In this guide, you will see where the classic advice still helps, where it falls short, and how your spending is more likely to look across your retirement years. Spoiler, it is more of a smile than a straight drop.
Prefer video over the blog? We’ve got you covered!
Watch our YouTube video as we dissect this blog post for you 🎥
The Classic 70 to 80 Percent Rule: What It Means and Why It Stuck
The old rule is simple: plan to spend about 70 to 80 percent of your working income in retirement. If you earned $100,000 a year, you would target $70,000 to $80,000 in annual spending after you clock out for good. It is tidy, easy to remember, and gets you moving in the right direction.
Why does this rule even make sense? Some big costs usually go away or shrink once you stop working:
- No payroll taxes from a paycheck, which lowers your outflow.
- No commuting costs, no gas, parking, trains, or rideshares twice a day.
- Less need for work clothes and dry cleaning.
- Many retirees have a paid-off home, which cuts a major monthly bill.
- Kids are out of the house. Though grandkids have a funny way of inviting new spending, think flights, gifts, and special trips.
- You stop saving into retirement plans, which frees up a chunk of cash.
You still see this rule quoted because large studies from places like the Department of Labor and firms such as Vanguard and Fidelity have referenced it for years. It is a proven starting point, much like the 4 percent withdrawal rule. And yes, that old chestnut had its testing roots in a very different interest rate world than the one you have lived in lately.
Here is the key: this rule is a baseline, not a blueprint. It helps you frame the conversation, but your real life is not a straight line. Housing, health, and taxes can push your spending around, sometimes a little, sometimes a lot. And habits are sticky. You are used to a certain lifestyle, and you tend to keep it.
Retirement Spending Patterns: The Smile That Replaces the Straight Drop
Your spending rarely falls off a cliff when you retire. It tends to form a curve that looks like a smile. The Society of Actuaries popularized that term, and it fits. You spend more early on, ease off in the middle, then spend more again later.
The Go-Go Years, Ages 65 to 74: High Spending Starts Strong
You retire, you feel great, and you want to enjoy the time you just earned. This is when you book the big trips, plan the family adventures, and say yes to the bucket list. Travel is the usual driver here, and it is not cheap. A few premium trips or that European river cruise can keep your total spending at working levels, or even push it higher for a while.
These years are fun, and they tend to be pricey. That is normal, and it does not mean your plan is off track.
The Middle Dip: When Things Slow Down
After the early excitement, spending often tapers. You still travel, just not as often or as far. You shift to routines closer to home. The smile dips in the middle, but it is rarely a sharp drop to 70 percent overnight. It is more of a gradual easing.
The Later Uptick: Health and Forced Withdrawals Push Costs Up
On the right side of the smile, costs start to creep up again. Two things usually do it:
- Healthcare needs rise with age. Even with Medicare, you will likely add supplemental coverage, and you may face costs tied to long-term care. If you retired before 65, the gap years before Medicare can be especially expensive.
- Required Minimum Distributions arrive. Depending on your situation, RMDs begin at age 73 or 75. That is the point when the IRS makes you pull money from pre-tax accounts. Larger withdrawals can increase your taxable income, which can nudge other costs up, too.
The combined effect is simple. Spending rarely drops as much as people expect. It can sit close to 100 percent in the go-go phase, ease off a bit, then rise later due to health needs and withdrawals you did not choose.
Big Changes Since the 1980s: Why the Old Rule Feels Outdated
One stat says it all. In the 1980s, about 42 percent of retirees were completely debt-free. Today, only about 22 percent are. That cuts the number of debt-free retirees in half. The big culprit is housing. More people carry a mortgage longer, even high earners. A mortgage is a fixed cost that keeps your monthly spending higher than the old rule assumed.
A paid-off home helps the 70 to 80 percent rule work. If you rent, that is still a fixed cost that will likely rise over time. If you kept renting because it was cheaper than a mortgage and you invested the difference, great. You still need to budget for housing as a core line item in retirement.
A small snapshot helps make this clear:
| Era | Share of retirees with zero debt | Main driver of debt |
|---|---|---|
| 1980s | 42 percent | Mostly mortgages |
| Today | 22 percent | Mostly mortgages |
That shift alone explains why many households do not see the dramatic drop they were promised.
Taxes: They Do Not Vanish
Yes, taxes might be lower in retirement, but they do not disappear. How you saved during your career sets the stage. If most of your money is in pre-tax accounts, RMDs can push your income higher and trigger more taxes. If more sits in Roth or taxable accounts, you have different levers. Either way, you need a plan.
Roth conversions can be a powerful tool, especially in lower-income years before RMDs begin. Converting on your terms can help reduce future RMDs and smooth your tax bill over time. Pull too much in one year, and a few dominoes can fall:
- You could face IRMAA surcharges on Medicare premiums.
- You might drift into a higher tax bracket.
- You could jump into higher capital gains brackets.
Pensions are less common now, and Social Security gets its fair share of scary headlines. That means you rely more on your portfolio. When your portfolio is your paycheck, taxes touch almost every withdrawal decision. Good planning here pays off.
Healthcare and Housing Realities
Healthcare costs keep moving higher. That is not breaking news, but it matters more when you are retired. Pay special attention to the years before Medicare if you stop working early. Then, plan for ongoing premiums, supplements, and unknowns like long-term care.
Housing is still a cornerstone. Mortgage or rent, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and updates are real. If your mortgage is gone, great. If not, do not count on a big spending drop until it is off your plate.
Modern Retiree Habits: Savings, Gifting, and Ongoing Planning
Here is something you might not expect. Many retirees keep saving. Not in the same way, but the habit sticks. You might gift to family or support causes you care about. You might use a Donor-Advised Fund or make Qualified Charitable Distributions from an IRA if you are charitably inclined and over 70.5. That can be tax-efficient and satisfying at the same time.
RMDs create another twist. You take what you must, then often reinvest what you do not need right away. The money stays at work, your system continues, and your spending does not fall just because you are retired.
Estate and legacy planning also show up here. If your estate could face taxes in the future, you might use trusts or other tools to move assets in a thoughtful way. That work is part of the plan, not just a side project.
All this ties into decumulation, which is simply the art of turning savings into a steady paycheck. During your career, it is save, save, save. In retirement, it is withdraw smartly, with taxes and timing in mind. For many younger folks, Social Security is treated as a bonus, not a base. That changes how you structure withdrawals.
Detailed cash flow work over 30 to 40 years helps you see how all of this fits together. The future is a cloudy crystal ball, sure, but a clear plan beats a rough rule every time.
What About That 4 Percent Rule?
Quick reality check. Much of the famous 4 percent rule testing came from a very different interest rate era. That does not make it useless; it just means you should view it as a guide, not a guarantee. Pair it with the spending smile, your debt picture, and your tax plan. Now you have something you can actually use.
Key Takeaways: Does Spending Drop, and What Should You Do?
The short answer, the 70 to 80 percent rule, is still a decent high-level target. Big firms and the Department of Labor have quoted it for years, and it helps you frame your plan. The long answer, your spending is more likely to follow a smile. Higher early on, a dip in the middle, and a rise later, thanks to health needs and required withdrawals.
Debt, taxes, and habits often keep spending higher than people assume. Mortgage balances last longer than they used to. Taxes still matter, sometimes more than you expect. And when you remove one big cost, you often fill the space with travel, family, or experiences. That is normal, and it is part of a healthy retirement.
Here is what to do next:
- Review your debts, especially housing. Decide if you want the mortgage gone by a target age.
- Plan for taxes and healthcare. Include IRMAA, Medicare supplements, and those pre-65 gap years if you retire early.
- Consider Roth strategies. Conversions can reduce future RMD strain and give you more control over income later.
- Map your smile. Sketch your go-go, slow-go, and later years, then budget for each phase.
- Stress test your plan. Run multi-decade cash flow projections and update them yearly.
Want help pressure testing your numbers or asking a specific question? Send it in and get fresh insights through the WealthKeel Weekly and question form.
You wanted a clean answer. Sorry, retirement spending is not a straight drop. It is a smile. Use 70 to 80 percent as a starting point, then layer in your housing, health, and tax reality. Build a plan you can live with, and update it as life happens. Your future self will thank you. And hey, if your mortgage disappears and you suddenly book more trips or spoil those grandkids, you will not be the first. Or the last.
Looking for a more thorough all-in-one spot for your financial life? Check out our free eBook: A Doctor’s Prescription to Comprehensive Financial Wellness [Yes, it will ask for your email 😉]