Pros and Cons of Being a VA Physician

Being a VA physician comes with its unique blend of ups and downs. This blog post topic, suggested by one of our YouTube viewers, Dr. Miller, dives deep into the benefits and drawbacks of serving as a physician in the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). If you’re considering this path or are already on it, this comprehensive guide will help you weigh your options effectively.

🎥 Prefer video over the blog? We’ve got you covered!

Watch our YouTube video as we dissect this blog post for you 🎥

Cons of Being a VA Physician

Pay

One of the most commonly discussed pitfalls among VA physicians is the pay scale. Although the average salary of a VA physician is around $250,000, which isn’t too far off from the average salary of physicians in general, the range can be quite broad. It’s helpful to break this down by tiers and specialties to get a clearer picture.

• Tier 1 for General Positions: Minimum salary for a Tier 1 VA physician starts at approximately $116,000, with a maximum of $243,000.
• Pathology and Psychiatry: The minimum remains at $116,000, but the maximum increase to around $282,000.
• Nuclear Medicine, Emergency Medicine, and Cardiology: The base salary starts at the same $116,000, with a maximum going up to $348,000.
• Unique Specialties (Anesthesia, Neurosurgery, Dermatology, Plastics, Urology, Gastroenterology, Vascular Surgery, Interventional Cardiology): These specialties also start at $116,000 but can reach as high as $400,000.

While these figures may seem appealing, the range itself poses a challenge. A $200,000 swing in salary is significant. Moreover, bonuses in the VA are usually capped at about $15,000 to $20,000, which pales in comparison to the often substantial bonuses found in private practice.

Government Job

Working for the VA means you’re working for the government, and with that comes a certain level of bureaucracy. The VA is a large, structured organization with processes and procedures you must adhere to. This rigid framework can be comforting for some but feels restrictive to others.

When you’re dealing with government protocols, expect a considerable amount of paperwork and red tape. For many VA physicians, this leads to frustration and burnout, particularly if you are someone who values flexibility and swift decision-making in your practice.

Disability Insurance

The VA’s disability insurance leaves much to be desired. Here are some of the main drawbacks:

• 18-Month Waiting Period: You need to work for a year and a half before you are eligible for group coverage.
• Difficult Qualification: The qualification criteria are similar to Social Security Disability, which is challenging to meet.
• Coverage Formula:
  • First Year: 60% of the average of your highest three years minus 100% of disability pay.
  • After First Year Until Age 62: Only 40% of your highest three years, and it’s taxable.

Given these limitations, it’s crucial to supplement with a private disability insurance policy to ensure you’re adequately covered.

Employee Forever

When you decide to take a VA physician role, you are essentially signing up to be an employee for the long haul. There are no opportunities for ownership or partnership within the VA system. For those who have dreams of owning their practice or climbing the ladder to partnership, this can be a significant drawback. This is why many physicians use the VA as a stepping stone early in their careers, especially to take advantage of the student loan benefits.

Pros of Being a VA Physician

Work-Life Balance

One significant advantage of being a VA physician is the consistent work-life balance. Unlike other medical roles that might demand extensive hours, many VA physicians report predictable schedules that allow for a healthy balance between work and personal life. Whether it’s ensuring you have weekends free to spend with family or having time to hit the golf course, you’re more likely to find a sustainable work-life balance within the VA system. This balance is crucial for avoiding burnout and enjoying a long, fulfilling career.

Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) – Government 401(k)

The Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) is another considerable benefit. The TSP is known for its simplicity, low-cost investment options, and a 5% employer match. Here’s what you can expect from the VA’s version of a 401(k):

• Low-Cost Funds: The TSP offers different funds such as the G fund, I fund, S fund, C fund, and target date funds, all at low management costs.
• 5% Employer Match: Contribute 5% of your salary to get the full employer match.
• No True-Up Provision: Ensure your contributions are spread evenly throughout the year to maximize the employer match.

Student Loan Programs

The VA offers excellent student loan repayment programs, which can be a massive boon, especially for younger physicians:

• Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF): Given that the VA is a government entity, you qualify for the PSLF program, which forgives the remaining balance on your Direct Loans after you’ve made 120 qualifying monthly payments under a qualifying repayment plan while working full-time for a qualifying employer.
• Education Debt Reduction Program (EDRP): This unique program can provide up to $40,000 per year for five years to help pay off your loans. It’s taxable, but it also applies to private loans, making it a versatile option for many physicians.

Pension

One of the standout benefits of working as a VA physician is access to a pension. Despite pensions becoming increasingly rare in the medical world, the VA still offers this benefit, making it a valuable part of your retirement planning:

• Contribution Rates: As a VA physician, you’ll contribute 4.4% of your salary, while the government contributes 16.5%.
• Vesting Requirements: You need to work for five years to be vested in the pension, while ten years of service makes you eligible for spousal benefits.

Licensing

Navigating medical licensing can be a headache, but with the VA, once you’re accredited, you’re covered for all 1,250 VA hospitals and facilities across various US territories. This flexibility is a considerable advantage if you want to work in different locations without the hassle of obtaining new licenses each time.

Deeper Value in Work

There’s a unique, intrinsic value in serving as a VA physician. Every day you get to help veterans who have dedicated part of their lives to serving our country. Additionally, this group often consists of individuals on the lower income spectrum, meaning your work can make a significant impact on those who might otherwise struggle to receive high-quality care. While this aspect might not be quantifiable in monetary terms, it certainly adds a fulfilling dimension to your career.

Conclusion

Being a VA physician comes with its own set of pros and cons. The key is to weigh these factors according to your personal and professional goals to determine whether this career path is suitable for you. From work-life balance and robust retirement plans to bureaucratic hurdles and salary limitations, the VA offers a distinct environment for physicians.

With a more in-depth understanding of both the advantages and drawbacks, you can make a well-informed decision about whether a role as a VA physician aligns with your aspirations and values. Thank you, Dr. Miller, for sparking this insightful discussion, and if you have any more questions or ideas, feel free to reach out.

For everyone considering this path or currently on it, good luck and thank you for your service in providing care to those who have served our nation.

 

Looking for a more thorough all-in-one spot for your financial life? Check out our free eBook: A Doctor’s Prescription to Comprehensive Financial Wellness [Yes, it will ask for your email 😉]

Disclosures